(Minor Fulfillment of Matt. 24/25 or Revelation
Oswald T. Allis
John A. Broadus
Wilhelm De Wette
Charles Homer Giblin
Johann von Hug
J, F, and Brown
Jean Le Clerc
Jack P. Lewis
Sir Isaac Newton
Dr. John Owen
William W. Patton
Rudolph E. Stier
(Major Fulfillment of Matt. 24/25 or Revelation
John L. Bray
Dr. John Brown
Francis X. Gumerlock
J. Marcellus Kik
Ovid Need, Jr
Milton S. Terry
(Virtually No Fulfillment of Matt. 24/25 & Revelation in 1st
C. - Types Only ; Also Included are "Higher Critics" Not Associated With Any
Alan Patrick Boyd
John N. Darby
Charles G. Finney
J.P. Green Sr.
John N.D. Kelly
Dr. John Smith
George Fox |
Margaret Fell (Fox) |
PRETERIST UNIVERSALISM |
"But the famous Kindome of
Christ and Christians began moe years then one thousand five hundred agon..
Therefore the notable binding of Satan began one thousand five hundred years
agon, and therefore is past long before our time."
(Christs Kingdome on Earth, p.
Christs kingdome on earth, opened according to the
Herein is examined, what Mr. Th. Brightman, Dr. J.
Alstede, Mr. I. Mede, Mr. H. Archer, The glympse of Sions glory, and
such as concurre in opinion with them, hold concerning the thousand
years of the saints reign with Christ, and of Satans binding: herein
also their arguments are answered.
1645 by Printed by R. Cotes
for S. Bowtell in London)
10/1/12: Thomas Hayne (1645)
Quoted in Heaven Upon Earth "But the famous Kindome of Christ and
Christians began moe years then one thousand five hundred agon..
Therefore the notable binding of Satan began one thousand five hundred
years agon, and therefore is past long before our time." (Christs
Kindome on Earth, p. 72)
Jeffrey K. Jue:
Heaven on Earth: Joseph Mede and the rise of millenarianism -
Section 8 - Challenges from Preterists (2006) This book
contributes to the ongoing revision of early modern British history by
examining the apocalyptic tradition through the life and writings of
Joseph Mede (1586-1638). The history of the British apocalyptic
tradition has yet to undergo a thorough revision. Past studies followed
a historiographical paradigm which associated millenarianism with a
revolutionary agenda. A careful study of Joseph Mede, one of the key
individuals responsible for the rebirth of millenarianism in England,
suggests a different picture of seventeenth-century apocalypticism. The
roots of Mede's apocalyptic thought are not found in extreme activism,
but in the detailed study of the Apocalypse with the aid of ancient
Christian and Jewish sources. Mede's legacy illustrates the geographical
prevalence and long-term sustainability of his interpretations. This
volume shows that the continual discussion of millenarian ideas reveals
a vibrant tradition that cannot be reconstructed to fit within one
simple historiographical narrative.
"Hayne went so far as
to argue that the coming of the Son of Man in the clouds in Daniel
referred exclusively to Christ's first coming. "Coming in the
Clouds, dan. 7. is not the last Judgment at Doomsday but Christ's
coming to take the Kingdom which he preached to be at hand, of all
power being given to him." (Mede, Works, pp. 740,752)
"The debate between
Mede and Thomas Hayne illustrates an important division that emerged
within the English apocalyptic tradition. The sixteenth century
marked the increase of the historical-prophetic exegetical method,
while the seventeenth century witnessed the dominance of this
hermeneutic. Yet within this historicist tradition in England, two
competing interpretations arose. The followers of Mede continued to
endose his millenarianism, while others like Thomas Hayne argued for
a preterist reading." (p. 150)
"The sixteenth century marked the
increase of the historical-prophetic exegetical method, while the
seventeenth century witnessed the dominance of this hermeneutic. Yet
within this historicist tradition in England, two competing
interpretations arose. The New England pastor, Increase Mather,
expressed his opinion of ...the
Dutch scholar Hugo Grotius and his most ardent English supporter Henry
Hammond in one of his dissertations:
for Grotius, I look on my self as concerned to warn young Scholars
to beware of him, lest they suck down Poison when they think they
have found Honey. He has by perverse Expositions and
Interpretations in his Annotations on the Bible, corrupter many
Texts of Scripture .. Dr. Hammond has borrowed most of his Nations
from Grotius (especially his apocalyptical ones) whoever compares
them will quickly discern."
"All millenarians in the same strand as Mede shared
Mather's scathing sentiments, because Grotius, Hammond and later the
puritan pastor Richard Baxter provided the strongest and most sustained
opposition against a millennarian eschatology." (Heaven and earth,
p. 150 "Katherine Firth describes their interpretation as a
"New Way," which solicited repeated responses from those who contained
to follow Mede."
EARLY CRITICAL DEBATE BETWEEN A
FUTURIST ESCHATOLOGY AND A MODERN PRETERIST ESCHATOLOGY : JOSEPH MEDE
VS. THOMAS HAYNE
In the end neither
nor Hayne surrendered any exegetical ground. Hayne
regarded Mede as his "worthy and learned friend, but not to bee
preferred before truth."
The debate between Mede and
Thomas Hayne illustrates an important division that emerged within
English apocalyptic tradition.
"But the famous Kingdome of Christ and
Christians began moe years then one thousand five hundred agon.. Therefore
the notable binding of Satan began one thousand five hundred years agon, and
therefore is past long before our time." (Christs Kingdome on Earth, p. 72)
"If the Roman Empire, Apoc. 13, be
resembled by a Beast which is composed of all Daniel's four Beasts, Dan. 7.
Or the chief parts of the four Beasts, then it is but sufficiently expressed
by them all." (First letter to Mede dated 5 June 1629. Mede,
Works, p. 735)
"The Fourth beast, Dan. 7. and the
first Beast, Revel. 13 are not one and the same: They differ much in shape
of body, and in their acts, and in their falls and plagues. Besides,
that in the Apocal. is made as it were of all the four in Daniel, and is so
described as if it came in stead, and was comparable to them all; as indeed
it was." (Second letter to Mede, undated, ibid. 741)
WHAT OTHERS HAVE SAID
Jeffrey K. Jue
"Significantly Hayne placed the beginning of the millennium of Apocalypse 20
in the first century with Christ's first advent, the ministry of the
Apostles and the destruction of Jerusalem."
"All that awaited fulfillment in Hayne's interpretation of the apocalyptic
drama was the return of Christ to throw the Devil, the beast and the false
prophet into the eternal lake of fire (20:10)." (Heaven on earth, p. 150)
"Hayne went so far as to argue that
the coming of the Son of Man in the clouds in Daniel referred exclusively to
Christ's first coming. "Coming in the clouds, Dan.7, is not the last
Judgment at Doomsday but Christ's coming to take the Kingdom which he
preached to be at hand, of all power being given to him."
still struggled to gain credibility within other Protestant countries,
especially England. The English commentator Thomas Hayne claimed that the
prophecies of Daniel had all been fulfilled by the 1st century (‘Christs
Kingdom on Earth’, 1645), and Joseph Hall expressed the same conclusion
concerning Daniel’s prophecies (‘The Revelation Unrevealed’, 1650), but
neither of them applied their Preterist views to Revelation. However, the
exposition of Grotius convinced the Englishman Henry Hammond. Hammond
sympathized with Grotius’ desire for unity among Christians, and found his
Preterist exposition useful to this end. Hammond wrote his own Preterist
exposition in 1653, borrowing extensively from Grotius. In his introduction
to Revelation he claimed that others had independently arrived at similar
conclusions as himself, though he gives pride of place to Grotius.
Hammond was Grotius’ only notable Protestant convert, and despite his
reputation and influence, Grotius’ interpretation of Revelation was
overwhelmingly rejected by Protestants and gained no ground for at least 100
Case for Biblical Universalism: Preterist Eschatology)
Thomas Hayne (1582–1645) was an English schoolmaster and theologian.
The son of Robert Hayne of Thrussington, Leicestershire, he matriculated
from Lincoln College, Oxford, on 12 October 1599. He was admitted B.A. on 23
January 1605, was appointed second under-master of Merchant Taylors' School,
London, in the same year, became usher at Christ's Hospital in 1608, and
commenced M.A. in 1612. He died on 27 July 1645, and was buried in Christ
Church, London, where a monument, destroyed in the Great Fire of London, was
erected to his memory. Anthony Wood describes him as a scholar particularly
respected by John Selden.
By will dated 20 September 1640 he bequeathed his books to the library at
Leicester, with the exception of a few which he left to the library at
Westminster. He also gave £400, to buy land or houses for the maintenance of
a schoolmaster at Thrussington to teach ten poor children, and bequeathed
£42 yearly for the maintenance of two scholars in Lincoln College, Oxford.
Other charitable bequests are included in his will.
Other gifts during his lifetime were towards the library of Sion
College; and of Minuscule 69, a significant manuscript, to the
Leicester library in 1640.
His works are:
* 'Linguarum cognatio, seu de Linguis in genere et de Variorum Lingarum
Harmoniii Dissertatio,' London. 1639. Reprinted in Thomas Crenius's 'Analecta
Philologico-Critico-Historica,' Amsterdam, 1699.
* 'Grammaticae Latine Compendium,' London, 1640.
* 'The equal wayes of God: for rectifying the unequal wayes of man. Briefly
and clearly drawn from the sacred Scriptures. . . . Second edition, revised
and . . . enlarged,' London, 1640.
* 'The Life and Death of Dr. Martin Luther, presented in an English dresse,
out of the learned and laborious work of Melchior Adam,' London, 1641.
* 'Of the Article of our Creed: Christ descended to Hades, or ad Inferos'
(anon.), London, 1642.
* 'Christs Kingdome on Earth, opened according to the Scriptures. Herein is
examined what Mr. Th. Brightman, Dr. J. Alstede, Mr. I. Mede, Mr. H. Archer,
The Glympse of Sions Glory, and such as concurre in opinion with them, hold
concerning the thousand years of the Saints Reign with Christ, and of Satans
binding,' London, 1645.
Hayne also published a 'General view of the Holy Scriptures; or the Times,
Places, and Persons of Holy Scripture,' 2nd edit., much enlarged, London,
1640. The first edition of this anonymous book was called 'Times, Places, &
Persons of the holie Scriptures. Otherwise entituled, The General View of
the Holy Scriptures' London, 1607.
1. ^ Thomas Hayne in Venn, J. & J. A., Alumni Cantabrigienses, Cambridge
University Press, 10 vols, 1922–1958.
2. ^ http://www.lambethpalacelibrary.org/files/2007_Annual_Review.pdf, p.
3. ^ Ernest Harold Pearce, Sion College and Library (1913), p. 247.
4. ^ Bruce Manning Metzger, Manuscripts of the Greek Bible: an introduction
to Greek palaeography (1981), p. 138.
What do YOU think ?
Submit Your Comments For Posting Here
..Will Be Spam
Filtered and Posted Shortly..